Source: PCT Magazine
Practical tips for what works and what doesn’t when marketing green pest management services.
Green: It’s ambiguous, ubiquitous and hotter than ever, even when consumers are pinching every penny.
According to the State of Green Business 2010 report by Greener World Media, green business activity not only survived the recession, it thrived. The report cited a study by Opinion Research Corp. that found four of five people still bought green products and services in the midst of the downturn.
Green, however, means many things to many people, which makes marketing green services a trickier proposition than you might think. It’s "far more perplexing than most marketers bargained for, requiring more complex and nuanced messages and value propositions," said Greener World Media Executive Editor Joel Makower.
Walking the Talk. The first hurdle: making sure you have an honest-to-goodness green service. Being accused of "greenwashing" — when a company spins its product or service as being green when it’s not — can be a marketing kiss of death.
"People lie," said Bud Brewer, vice chairman at Orlando-based Massey Communications, which works with Massey Services. They "set expectations that they can never achieve."
Environmental Health Services in Norwood, Mass., is careful not to "oversell" its green offering, said General Manager George Williams. The company has focused on managing pests through Integrated Pest Management practices since 1986. "If you’re smart about selling green services, you’re selling IPM," said Williams.
Your Thoughts on Green
PCT took readers’ collective "green" pulse in May 2008 and April 2010. Here’s what we learned: Seventeen percent more of you offer "green" pest management services and eight percent more are actively marketing these services in 2010 compared to 2008.
In 2010, more of you consider mechanical devices (+13%), EPA-exempt products (+12%) and Integrated Pest Management (+ 12%) as being green services. An increasing number of you also said green products are compatible with IPM programs (+9%), with low active ingredient content (+8%), low impact on human health (+8%) and low use rates (+8%).
Here are some results of the PCT online surveys:
In mid-1990, Massey Services changed its service protocol to focus on pest prevention, said Brewer. "It was an enormous departure" from the practices of the day, which often involved "indiscriminate application of pesticides in and around the home whether it was needed or not."
Since then, Massey Services has been recognized twice by the Environmental Protection Agency’s Pesticide and Environmental Stewardship Program, as well as by local organizations.
When the National Pest Management Association developed its GreenPro certification and a "credible, concrete process for conducting a green approach to pest management," Mark O’Hara, president of Anderson Pest Solutions in Elmhurst, Ill., decided it was time to make a change.
The company, which had eliminated the spraying of pesticides indoors for residential accounts years ago, became GreenPro certified last November. It also renamed its primary services Natural Choice Home and Natural Choice Commercial, which aim to "reduce and eliminate the use of pesticides if possible through eliminating conducive conditions," explained O’Hara.
Clark Pest Control in Lodi, Calif., — "ground zero" for the green movement, said Operations Manager Robert Baker — unveiled its S.M.A.R.T. philosophy and service program about six months ago. Standing for Sustainable Methods and Responsible Treatments, S.M.A.R.T. is a less-toxic, inspection-based service with products that are "generally regarded as safe," according to the company website.
The program’s had a "huge impact on our protocols" and product selection, and reinforces the company’s commitment to keeping pesticides out of stream and storm water, said Baker. The company won the California Department of Pesticide Regulations 2009 IPM Innovator Award for its efforts to find a replacement for pyrethroid pesticides for residential pest control.
S.M.A.R.T. was marketed internally for a year and quietly field tested before being unveiled to customers. It was important to make the program part of the company culture and know it was something "we could live up to" before promising it to customers, said Marketing Manager Nicole Kirwan Keefe.
"With every political pronouncement and product pitch, the green movement is getting too close to the edge of cliché and public skepticism," said Environmental Health Services Operations Vice President Sabrina Key. "We know we have to walk a fine line and offer a truly viable and tangible green service when the customer demands it."
Pinpoint Your Message. An October 2007 Harris Poll commissioned by NPMA found 61 percent of those who use a pest professional for their home say they seek out solutions they perceive to be, or are advertised as, green. More women — 69 percent — than men are likely to say they seek out green pest solutions.
Yet the concept still is a reach for many consumers, said Keefe. In focus groups, she found "people are skeptical." One participant called green pest management an oxymoron. Another identified green pest management as "an anteater." Consumers aren’t equally green in all areas of their lives. "They apply it to their Prius but they don’t apply it to their pest control," she said.
So why not market IPM, something professionals have been doing for years? It means nothing to most consumers, said Baker. IPM on its own has "zero marketing value."
The key is to define your green. The words "sustainable" and "responsible" in Clark Pest Control’s S.M.A.R.T. program are "clear cut" and convey what Clark is trying to achieve, said Keefe. Service tickets, press releases, door hangers and brochures explain how the service is different and why customers should feel good about working with Clark, she said.
Anderson Pest Solutions’ new tag-line, The Natural Choice, is a double entendre that implies both a green service approach and that they’re the best company for the job. A newly designed logo, website, residential and commercial collateral pieces, and decaled trucks send home the message.
Environmental Health Services uses the tagline, "It’s Your World, Protect It!" This implies consumers have an environmental obligation and that effective pest management is a partnership. "We truly are protectors of public health and the environment and this is the best message we can deliver," Williams said. Added President John Stellberger, "EHS was green when green was just a color!"
Tactics like search-engine and social media optimization, viral video, pay-per-click advertising and e-mail "help reinforce our identity and brand," said Williams. "So do our field specialists and office staff — they are our greatest resource for educating customers."
Massey Services’ "straightforward" message of prevention has "resonated" with consumers, said Brewer. "It’s not ambiguous and it’s not something we can’t deliver." It works: Massey has grown in each of its 25 years, with double-digit growth in 18 of them. Upscale single-family homeowners, mainly women, are targeted through broadcast and cable TV, radio, direct marketing and community engagement. The emphasis is on value, effectiveness and efficiency, said Brewer.
Consumers are more willing to go green when the benefits are personal and planetary, said Makower. They want products that "aren’t just greener, but better," such as less expensive, more features or better performance, more convenient, less wasteful, healthier for their families, or simply cool, he said.
They want to know green service is "going to deliver results," agreed Keefe.
GreenPro: One Year Later
It’s been a busy year for the NPMA GreenPro credentialing program. Not only will it have certified 100 companies by mid-summer, but it’s gained valuable "street credibility," said NPMA Senior Vice President Bob Rosenberg.
In December, the EPA presented NPMA with its National Pesticide Program Partners Award for GreenPro at the first-ever Honor Awards Ceremony.
GreenPro companies now are automatically qualified to become gold-level EPA Environmental Stewardship Partners, which gives them limited use of the EPA name and lets them make certain marketing claims they otherwise couldn’t, said Rosenberg.
It’s got some bottom-line benefits, too.
Credentials like GreenPro are required to bid in the Department of Housing and Urban Development’s Mark-to-Market program, which makes Integrated Pest Management available to affordable housing, said QualityPro Executive Director Andrew Architect.
Others requiring certification include the state of Delaware, Canadian Department of Defense and the U.S. Green Building Council’s LEED program.
A member in Virginia Beach got GreenPro standards adopted at the Department of Energy. This gave that member a "distinct marketing advantage" and access to business other companies cannot compete for, said Architect.
GreenPro is a voluntary program and members don’t have to provide GreenPro service for every account. Rosenberg estimates five to 10 percent of member accounts get GreenPro service. Commercial accounts have been faster to adopt the service than residential ones.
The GreenPro advisory committee consists of five PMPs and four industry outsiders — including the EPA and Natural Resources Defense Council. The industry’s commitment, Rosenberg said, has tempered outsiders’ skepticism. "I think they’re fairly impressed."
"It’s been a very positive experience" for NPMA, QualityPro and the industry, said Rosenberg.
Green Do’s and Don’ts. This should come as no surprise: When marketing green stay away from powder-keg words, advised professionals.
Never say "safe," said Brewer. Describe your service as environmentally responsible, like Anderson Pest Solutions, or having a minimal impact on the environment.
Environmental Health Services steers clear of non-toxic terminology, said Williams. Instead, EHS provides "eco-sensitive pest solutions." Clark Pest Control offers services that are "environmentally sensitive." Williams advises limiting or avoiding use of the word "green," because it is being overplayed in the consumer market. Brand your services so green is perceived, such as by using earth-tone colors and earth-friendly text and images, Williams said. Explain services clearly and drop the jargon, or the "scope of service is lost in translation," he added. Analogies can help customers visualize and relate to the treatment process.
And set realistic expectations, advised Brewer. Manage those expectations appropriately, especially when dealing with customers one-on-one.
Remember, professionals are subject to state and federal restrictions when advertising green pest control, said NPMA Senior Vice President Bob Rosenberg. About 20 states have taken "fairly serious enforcement action" against companies that have made health, safety or environmental claims over the last 20 years, with hundreds paying large penalties, he said.
Third-party green credentials like GreenShield and GreenPro let professionals communicate a different kind of service without the risk of becoming a target of enforcement action, Rosenberg said.
How Goes Green? At present, green pest management has mixed customer appeal. Anderson Pest Solutions’ commercial clients have quickly and enthusiastically embraced GreenPro service, which also appeals to a segment of residential customers, said O’Hara.
But a large number of residential customers remain neutral on GreenPro, and a small group prefers to continue conventional treatment, he said.
Environmental Health Services does offer a total "organic package" in addition to its eco-sensitive approach, but "it is not requested as much as you would think," said Williams.
PCOs remain committed to the shift. "I’m doing it because I believe in it," said O’Hara.
"Without a doubt" it is the future of the industry, said Baker. In 1999, Clark Pest Control launched a green service that failed. Green awareness hadn’t reached a critical mass, he recalled. Now, it’s becoming "hard to ignore."
In fact, 17 percent more professionals offer green pest management services and eight percent are more actively marketing these services in 2010 than 2008, according to online surveys conducted by PCT.
Future legislation is a wild card, reminded Keefe. Focusing on sustainability will help ensure the industry’s future.
For Anderson Pest Solutions providing green pest management now will "put us that much ahead of the curve," said O’Hara.
The author is a frequent contributor to PCT magazine. E-mail her at email@example.com.
Visit the Clark Pest Blog
or visit ClarkPest.com
to learn more.
One of the better articles ive read!
The world is going green. "Green" is the color of environmental concern, the impetus that drives cutting-edge technology, the buzz word of the socially conscious. Concern for the environment and man's impact on it is bringing a slew of new products to market, and pest control is no exception. Environmentally-friendly pest control services are growing in popularity, particularly in the commercial sector. Even eco-savvy residential consumers are asking about natural alternatives to traditional pesticides, but their ardor often cools when confronted with the 10% to 20% cost differential and lengthier treatment times, sometimes several weeks.
The raising of America's environmental consciousness, coupled with increasingly stringent federal regulations governing traditional chemical pesticides, appears to be shifting the pest control industry's focus to Integrated Pest Management (IPM) techniques. IPM is considered not only safer for the environment, but safer for people, pets and secondary scavengers such as owls. Of 378 pest management companies surveyed in 2008 by Pest Control Technology magazine, two-thirds said they offered IPM services of some sort.
Instead of lacing pest sites with a poisonous cocktail of powerful insecticides designed to kill, IPM focuses on environmentally-friendly prevention techniques designed to keep pests out. While low- or no-toxicity products may also be used to encourage pests to pack their bags, elimination and control efforts focus on finding and eliminating the causes of infestation: entry points, attractants, harborage and food.
Particularly popular with schools and nursing homes charged with guarding the health of the nation's youngest and oldest citizens, those at greatest risk from hazardous chemicals, IPM is catching the attention of hotels, office buildings, apartment complexes and other commercial enterprises, as well as eco-conscious residential customers. Driven in equal parts by environmental concerns and health hazard fears, interest in IPM is bringing a host of new environmentally-friendly pest management products -- both high- and low-tech -- to market.
"Probably the best product out there is a door sweep," confided Tom Green, president of the Integrated Pest Management Institute of North America, a non-profit organization that certifies green exterminating companies. In an Associated Press interview posted on MSNBC online last April, Green explained, "A mouse can squeeze through a hole the size of a pencil diameter. So if you've got a quarter-inch gap underneath your door, as far as a mouse is concerned, there's no door there at all." Cockroaches can slither through a one-eighth inch crevice.
IPM is "a better approach to pest control for the health of the home, the environment and the family," said Cindy Mannes, spokeswoman for the National Pest Management Association, the $6.3 billion pest control industry's trade association, in the same Associated Press story. However, because IPM is a relatively new addition to the pest control arsenal, Mannes cautioned that there is little industry consensus on the definition of green services.
In an effort to create industry standards for IPM services and providers, the Integrated Pest Management Institute of North America developed the Green Shield Certified (GSC) program. Identifying pest control products and companies that eschew traditional pesticides in favor of environmentally-friendly control methods, GSC is endorsed by the EPA, Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) and HUD. IPM favors mechanical, physical and cultural methods to control pests, but may use bio-pesticides derived from naturally-occurring materials such as animals, plants, bacteria and certain minerals.
Toxic chemical sprays are giving way to new, sometimes unconventional, methods of treating pests. Some are ultra high-tech like the quick-freeze Cryonite process for eliminating bed bugs. Others, like trained dogs that sniff out bed bugs, seem decidedly low-tech, but employ state-of-the-art methods to achieve results. For example, farmers have used dogs' sensitive noses to sniff out problem pests for centuries; but training dogs to sniff out explosives and drugs is a relatively recent development. Using those same techniques to teach dogs to sniff out termites and bed bugs is considered cutting-edge.
Another new pest control technique is birth control. When San Francisco was threatened by mosquitoes carrying potentially life-threatening West Nile Virus, bicycle messengers were hired to cruise the city and drop packets of biological insecticide into the city's 20,000 storm drains. A kind of birth control for mosquitoes, the new method was considered safer than aerial spraying with the chemical pyrethrum, the typical mosquito abatement procedure, according to a recent story posted on the National Public Radio website.
Naturally, there are efforts underway to build a better mousetrap. The innovative Track & Trap system attracts mice or rats to a food station dusted with fluorescent powder. Rodents leave a blacklight-visible trail that allows pest control experts to seal entry paths. Coming soon, NightWatch uses pheromone research to lure and trap bed bugs. In England, a sonic device designed to repel rats and squirrels is being tested, and the aptly named Rat Zapper is purported to deliver a lethal shock using just two AA batteries.
Alongside this influx of new environmentally-friendly products rides a posse of federal regulations. Critics of recent EPA regulations restricting the sale of certain pest-killing chemicals accuse the government of unfairly limiting a homeowner's ability to protect his property. The EPA's 2004 banning of the chemical diazinon for household use a couple of years ago removed a potent ant-killer from the homeowner's pest control arsenal. Similarly, 2008 EPA regulations prohibiting the sale of small quantities of effective rodenticides, unless sold inside an enclosed trap, has stripped rodent-killing chemicals from the shelves of hardware and home improvement stores, limiting the homeowner's ability to protect his property and family from these disease-carrying pests.
Acting for the public good, the government's pesticide-control actions are particularly aimed at protecting children. According to a May 20, 2008 report on CNN online, a study conducted by the American Association of Poison Control Centers indicated that rat poison was responsible for nearly 60,000 poisonings between 2001 and 2003, 250 of them resulting in serious injuries or death. National Wildlife Service testing in California found rodenticide residue in every animal tested.
Consumers are embracing the idea of natural pest control and environmentally-friendly, cutting-edge pest management products and techniques. Availability and government regulations are increasingly limiting consumers' self-treatment options, forcing them to turn to professional pest control companies for relief from pest invasions. While this has proved a viable option for commercial customers, few residential customers seem willing to pay higher prices for newer, more labor-intensive green pest control products and even fewer are willing to wait the additional week or two it may take these products to work. It is taking leadership efforts on the part of pest control companies to educate consumers in the long term benefits of green and natural pest treatments.
Even though the cold, hard truth is that when people have a pest problem, they want it gone and they want it gone now! If rats or mice are in their house destroying their property and threatening their family with disease, if termites or carpenter ants are eating away their home equity, if roaches are invading their kitchen or if they're sharing their bed with bed bugs, consumer interest in environmental friendliness plummets. When people call a pest control company, the bottom line is that they want the pests dead! Now! Pest control firms are standing up against the tide of consumer demand for immediate eradication by enhancing their natural and green pest control product offerings. These new natural products take the most responsible long term approach to pest control; one that protects our environment, children, and our own health. Sometimes it is lonely moving against the tide of popular demand, but true leadership, in the pest control industry, means embracing these new organic and natural technologies even when they are not popular with the consumer - yet.
Douglas Stern is the managing partner of Stern Environmental Group and a bed bug extermination expert. His firm serves commercial and residential clients in New Jersey, New York City, New York, and Connecticut. His firm is located at 100 Plaza Drive in Secaucus, New Jersey. You can reach him toll free at 1-888-887-8376. Please visit us on the Web at http://www.sternenvironmental.com/.
Visit the Clark Pest Blog
or visit ClarkPest.com
to learn more.